Thiamin, reaction and memory
Reaction and memory test results in young women with adequate B1 status.
Key points
- In a study of young adult women with adequate thiamin status, reaction in tests was faster than with placebo after two months of thiamin. For similar tests there is a preliminary signal of faster reaction in this group. [1] See the evidence 1
- In a study of young women with adequate thiamin status, no improvement in memory was found compared with placebo. This comparison does not justify expecting a confirmed improvement in memory. [1] See the evidence 1
Practical guide
Check the conclusions and whether they apply to your situation.
Reaction speed and memory were measured separately.
Key points
Why these conclusions
The test study
Young adult women with adequate thiamin status took 50 mg thiamin tablets or placebo daily for two months. Reaction in tests was faster, but no improvement in memory was found; certainty in both outcomes is very low. The thiamin salt was unspecified. [1]
Supplements may contain thiamin mononitrate and hydrochloride, as well as benfotiamine. Evidence for one form does not prove the same effect for another. [2]
In young women with adequate thiamin status, reaction was faster than with placebo.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | In young women with adequate thiamin status, reaction was faster than with placebo. Reaction time after thiamin was shorter than with placebo. |
| Participants | 120 young adult women with adequate thiamin status by the conventional criterion |
| Form | Oral thiamin tablets; salt unspecified |
| Dose | 50 mg thiamin daily |
| Dose basis | 50 mg thiamin daily |
| Comparator | Placebo |
| Duration | 2 months |
| Confidence | 1/4: Study methods: Small studies, incomplete text or substantial losses; an independent full RoB 2 assessment has not been performed. Consistency: Results, forms or clinical groups differ; few independent replications. Applicability to the specified group: A special population, different derivative or surrogate outcome limits transferability. Precision: Small sample, uncertainty interval or between-group comparison not extracted. Possible publication bias: Insufficient data for a confident assessment; unverified does not mean absent. |
| Evidence base | 1 placebo-controlled trial (120 participants; reaction and memory are from the same study group) |
| Sources | [1] |
In young women with adequate thiamin status, no improvement in memory was found compared with placebo.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | In young women with adequate thiamin status, no improvement in memory was found compared with placebo. No improvement in memory was found compared with placebo. |
| Participants | 120 young adult women with adequate thiamin status by the conventional criterion |
| Form | Oral thiamin tablets; salt unspecified |
| Dose | 50 mg thiamin daily |
| Dose basis | 50 mg thiamin daily |
| Comparator | Placebo |
| Duration | 2 months |
| Confidence | 1/4: Study methods: Small studies, incomplete text or substantial losses; an independent full RoB 2 assessment has not been performed. Consistency: Results, forms or clinical groups differ; few independent replications. Applicability to the specified group: A special population, different derivative or surrogate outcome limits transferability. Precision: Small sample, uncertainty interval or between-group comparison not extracted. Possible publication bias: Insufficient data for a confident assessment; unverified does not mean absent. |
| Evidence base | 1 placebo-controlled trial (120 participants; reaction and memory are from the same study group) |
| Sources | [1] |
Supplements may contain thiamin mononitrate and hydrochloride, as well as benfotiamine. Evidence for one form does not prove the same effect for another.
Supplements may contain thiamin mononitrate and hydrochloride, as well as benfotiamine. Evidence for one form does not prove the same effect for another. [2]
More details
What the tests showed
Reaction and memory are different outcomes of one trial; the accepted record does not provide the numerical size of the reaction-speed difference. [1]
Sources
- Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9122365/
- NIH ODS Thiamin Fact Sheet for Consumers. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Thiamin-Consumer/
Methodology: Subpages evidence-led supplement pipeline v1