| IBD-F fatigue | In adults with IBD in remission and chronic fatigue, fatigue decreased more than with placebo.Mean change −4.5 (95% CI −6.2…−2.6) versus +0.75 (−1.3…+2.8) points; p=0.0003 for the crossover comparison. | 2/4 LowStudy methods: A small study, analysis limitations and/or multiple comparisons. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: The measurement directly answers the specific narrow study question. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised crossover trial (40 enrolled; repeated periods in the same participants)Randomised clinical trial: high-dose oral thiamine versus placebo for chronic fatigue in patients with quiescent inflammatory bowel disease ↗ | 40 adults with IBD in remission and chronic fatigue | - Randomised clinical trial: high-dose oral thiamine versus placebo for chronic fatigue in patients with quiescent inflammatory bowel disease ↗
|
|---|
| PBC-40 fatigue | In primary biliary cholangitis, no fatigue advantage over placebo was found.+0.3 versus −1.4 points, p=0.55. | 2/4 LowStudy methods: A small study, analysis limitations and/or multiple comparisons. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: The measurement directly answers the specific narrow study question. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised crossover trial (36 randomised, 34 completed)High-dose oral thiamine versus placebo for chronic fatigue in patients with primary biliary cholangitis: A crossover randomized clinical trial ↗ | 36 patients with primary biliary cholangitis and chronic fatigue, 34 completed | - High-dose oral thiamine versus placebo for chronic fatigue in patients with primary biliary cholangitis: A crossover randomized clinical trial ↗
|
|---|
| Six-minute walking distance | In chronic heart failure, no convincing advantage over placebo in six-minute walking distance was found.No convincing between-group advantage was established. | 2/4 LowStudy methods: A small study, analysis limitations and/or multiple comparisons. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: The measurement directly answers the specific narrow study question. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (69 randomised; walking and quality of life in one trial)Thiamin supplementation does not improve left ventricular ejection fraction in ambulatory heart failure patients: a randomized controlled trial ↗ | 69 outpatients with chronic heart failure and reduced ejection fraction | - Thiamin supplementation does not improve left ventricular ejection fraction in ambulatory heart failure patients: a randomized controlled trial ↗
|
|---|
| Quality of life | In chronic heart failure, no convincing advantage over placebo in quality of life was found.No convincing between-group advantage was established. | 2/4 LowStudy methods: A small study, analysis limitations and/or multiple comparisons. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: The measurement directly answers the specific narrow study question. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (69 randomised; walking and quality of life in one trial)Thiamin supplementation does not improve left ventricular ejection fraction in ambulatory heart failure patients: a randomized controlled trial ↗ | 69 outpatients with chronic heart failure and reduced ejection fraction | - Thiamin supplementation does not improve left ventricular ejection fraction in ambulatory heart failure patients: a randomized controlled trial ↗
|
|---|
| Psychological PMS symptoms | A reduction in psychological symptoms compared with starch tablets was reported in female students with PMS; the effect size is very uncertain.In table 4, the published score reduction was 35.08±0.50 with vitamin B1 and 0.08±0.46 with placebo. | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: 20% excluded after randomisation; unclear allocation concealment and contradictory descriptions of scales and p values. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: A narrow sample and unspecified salt limit extrapolation. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (100 randomised, 80 analysed; two PMS domains in one trial)The effects of vitamin B1 on ameliorating the premenstrual syndrome symptoms ↗ | 100 female students with PMS randomised; 80 analysed, 40 per group | - The effects of vitamin B1 on ameliorating the premenstrual syndrome symptoms ↗
|
|---|
| Physical PMS symptoms | A reduction in physical symptoms compared with starch tablets was reported in female students with PMS; the effect size is very uncertain.Physical symptoms decreased more with vitamin B1 than with placebo. The 21.2% stated in the abstract is the reduction from baseline in the B1 group. | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: 20% excluded after randomisation; unclear allocation concealment and contradictory descriptions of scales and p values. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: A narrow sample and unspecified salt limit extrapolation. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (100 randomised, 80 analysed; two PMS domains in one trial)The effects of vitamin B1 on ameliorating the premenstrual syndrome symptoms ↗ | 100 female students with PMS randomised; 80 analysed, 40 per group | - The effects of vitamin B1 on ameliorating the premenstrual syndrome symptoms ↗
|
|---|
| Bleeding days | Women with increased bleeding or spotting after insertion of a TCu380A copper IUD had fewer bleeding days than with placebo.MD −2.00 days (95% CI −2.38…−1.62). | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: Dropouts 2 versus 14; the primary abstract states 110 without the full randomisation flow. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: Applicability is limited to the specific IUD and selected women; salt unknown. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (126 randomised, 110 analysed; the review describes the same trial)The effect of vitamin B1 on bleeding and spotting in women using an intrauterine device: a double-blind randomised controlled trial ↗ | Women in Iran with increased bleeding or spotting one month after insertion of a TCu380A copper IUD; 126 randomised according to Cochrane, 110 analysed | - The effect of vitamin B1 on bleeding and spotting in women using an intrauterine device: a double-blind randomised controlled trial ↗
|
|---|
| Spotting days | Women with increased bleeding or spotting after insertion of a TCu380A copper IUD had fewer spotting days than with placebo.MD −1.60 days (95% CI −1.94…−1.26). | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: Dropouts 2 versus 14; the primary abstract states 110 without the full randomisation flow. Consistency of results: There are no grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the stated group: Applicability is limited to the specific IUD and selected women; salt unknown. Precision of the estimate: A small sample or insufficient precision of the comparative estimate. Possible publication bias: There are no specific data for a separate downgrade. | 11 randomised trial (126 randomised, 110 analysed; the review describes the same trial)The effect of vitamin B1 on bleeding and spotting in women using an intrauterine device: a double-blind randomised controlled trial ↗ | Women in Iran with increased bleeding or spotting one month after insertion of a TCu380A copper IUD; 126 randomised according to Cochrane, 110 analysed | - The effect of vitamin B1 on bleeding and spotting in women using an intrauterine device: a double-blind randomised controlled trial ↗
|
|---|
| Reaction speed | Young women with adequate thiamine intake reacted faster than with placebo.Reaction time after taking thiamine was shorter than with placebo. | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: Small studies, incomplete text or substantial attrition; an independent full RoB 2 risk-of-bias assessment was not performed. Consistency of results: Outcomes, forms or clinical groups differ; few independent replications. Applicability to the stated group: A specific population, different derivative or surrogate outcome limits extrapolation. Precision of the estimate: Small sample, uncertainty interval or between-group comparison not extracted. Possible publication bias: Insufficient data for a confident assessment; unchecked does not mean absent. | 11 placebo-controlled trial (120 women; reaction and memory in the same study group)Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning ↗ | 120 young adult women with adequate thiamine status by the traditional criterion | - Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning ↗
|
|---|
| Memory | No memory improvement compared with placebo was found in young women with adequate thiamine status.No memory improvement compared with placebo was found. | 1/4 Very lowStudy methods: Small studies, incomplete text or substantial attrition; an independent full RoB 2 risk-of-bias assessment was not performed. Consistency of results: Outcomes, forms or clinical groups differ; few independent replications. Applicability to the stated group: A specific population, different derivative or surrogate outcome limits extrapolation. Precision of the estimate: Small sample, uncertainty interval or between-group comparison not extracted. Possible publication bias: Insufficient data for a confident assessment; unchecked does not mean absent. | 11 placebo-controlled trial (120 women; reaction and memory in the same study group)Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning ↗ | 120 young adult women with adequate thiamine status by the traditional criterion | - Thiamine supplementation mood and cognitive functioning ↗
|
|---|