Vitamin D2 and D3: how to choose a form

How D2 and D3 differ, how to compare drops and capsules, and how to convert micrograms into international units.

Key points

  • D2 and D3 are different forms of vitamin D. Check the package for the form and amount per serving. [1] See the evidence 1
  • In adults, D3 generally raised blood vitamin D levels more than D2. This can be considered when choosing a form. [2] See the evidence 1
  • One microgram of vitamin D equals 40 IU. This helps compare amounts on different packages. [1] See the evidence 1

Practical guide

Please double-check the conclusions and consider your own circumstances when choosing a supplement.

You can check the form and amount of vitamin D on the label. Pay attention to the stated serving size.

Choosing the form and amount

Why these conclusions

Form, serving size and comparison of D2 and D3

D2 is called ergocalciferol and D3 cholecalciferol. D2 is usually derived from yeast, while D3 is usually derived from lanolin. Lichen-derived D3 is also available. [1]

In studies of adults, D3 generally raised blood 25(OH)D more than D2. An advantage of D3 for fractures or well-being has not been shown. [2]

When comparing oil capsules and powder, check the vitamin D content per serving, the ingredients and ease of use. The sources cited here do not directly compare ordinary oil capsules with powder. [1]

D2 is ergocalciferol and D3 is cholecalciferol; check the form and amount on the label when choosing a product. D2 is usually derived from yeast, D3 usually from lanolin; lichen-derived D3 is also available.

ParameterData
ResultD2 is ergocalciferol and D3 is cholecalciferol; check the form and amount on the label when choosing a product. D2 is usually derived from yeast, D3 usually from lanolin; lichen-derived D3 is also available.
ParticipantsPeople buying vitamin D, including those avoiding animal products
FormD2 ergocalciferol; D3 cholecalciferol
DoseNo dose specified: a question of identity
Dose basiscomposition and amount per labelled serving
ComparisonNot applicable: a descriptive fact or an organisation’s recommendation, not a comparison of study groups.
DurationNot applicable: the source describes a fact or standard, not an observation over a fixed period.
ConfidenceA descriptive fact, summary of an official recommendation or rule; the effectiveness rating scale does not apply.
Volume of evidenceNamed sources: 1
Sources[1]

Compare the vitamin D content per serving, the ingredients and ease of use. The permitted sources do not directly compare ordinary oil capsules with powder.

ParameterData
ResultCompare the vitamin D content per serving, the ingredients and ease of use. The permitted sources do not directly compare ordinary oil capsules with powder.
ParticipantsPeople buying vitamin D supplements
Formoil capsules and powder products
DoseThe dose depends on the product selected
Dose basisamount of vitamin D per stated serving
ComparisonNot applicable: a descriptive fact or an organisation’s recommendation, not a comparison of study groups.
DurationNot applicable: the source describes a fact or standard, not an observation over a fixed period.
ConfidenceA descriptive fact, summary of an official recommendation or rule; the effectiveness rating scale does not apply.
Volume of evidenceNamed sources: 1
Sources[1]

1 µg of vitamin D equals 40 IU; for example, 15 µg = 600 IU. Check how many units of the product make up a serving.

ParameterData
Result1 µg of vitamin D equals 40 IU; for example, 15 µg = 600 IU. Check how many units of the product make up a serving.
ParticipantsPeople buying vitamin D and reading labels
FormD2 and D3
Dose1 µg = 40 IU; 15 µg = 600 IU
Dose basismass of vitamin D per serving
ComparisonNot applicable: a descriptive fact or an organisation’s recommendation, not a comparison of study groups.
DurationNot applicable: the source describes a fact or standard, not an observation over a fixed period.
ConfidenceA descriptive fact, summary of an official recommendation or rule; the effectiveness rating scale does not apply.
Volume of evidenceNamed sources: 1
Sources[1]

Check the label for the amount of vitamin D and number of drops per serving; calculate the amount per drop by dividing the amount by the number of drops per serving.

ParameterData
ResultCheck the label for the amount of vitamin D and number of drops per serving; calculate the amount per drop by dividing the amount by the number of drops per serving.
ParticipantsPeople buying liquid vitamin D
Formliquid vitamin D drops
DoseDepends on the specific label
Dose basisamount per serving divided by number of drops per serving
ComparisonNot applicable: a descriptive fact or an organisation’s recommendation, not a comparison of study groups.
DurationNot applicable: the source describes a fact or standard, not an observation over a fixed period.
ConfidenceA descriptive fact, summary of an official recommendation or rule; the effectiveness rating scale does not apply.
Volume of evidenceNamed sources: 1
Sources[1]

D3 generally raised the laboratory marker more than D2; clinical superiority for fractures or well-being has not been demonstrated.

ParameterData
ResultWith daily D2, the increase in 25(OH)D was 10.39 nmol/L lower than with D3 (95% CI −14.62 to −6.16). After excluding high-risk studies, the difference was −7.27 nmol/L (−14.67 to 0.14).
ParticipantsAdults in 12 comparisons of daily use
Formoral D2 and D3
DoseDoses varied between studies
Dose basisDoses and regimens of individual studies
ComparisonD3
DurationVaried between studies
Confidencelow 2/4: Limitations of individual studies and an incomplete formal assessment; no substantial inconsistency was identified or there was only one study; the conclusion is limited to the stated population and outcomes; small sample, wide interval or imprecise estimate; a full assessment is not possible; funnel plot asymmetry for respiratory outcomes is noted separately.
Volume of evidenceNamed sources: 1
Sources[2]

More details

How to calculate the amount per drop

For drops, divide the amount of vitamin D per serving by the number of drops in that serving. For example, 15 µg equals 600 IU. [1]

Sources

  1. Vitamin D - Health Professional Fact Sheet. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-HealthProfessional/
  2. van den Heuvel et al. 2024: systematic review of vitamin D2 versus D3. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10831883/

Methodology: Subpages evidence-led supplement pipeline v1

Ingredient overview: Vitamin D