Vitamin A: forms, RAE and intake values
How to distinguish retinol, beta-carotene, RAE units and total intake reference values.
Key points
- Retinol and its esters are preformed vitamin A, while beta-carotene is a provitamin carotenoid; their contributions to RAE differ. Check the form and units on the label before comparing amounts. [1] See the evidence 1 2
- In the United States, the RDA for total intake in adults is 900 µg RAE per day for men and 700 µg RAE for women. Consider food and supplements together when comparing with the reference. [1] See the evidence 1
- In a long-term group of 4052 men older than 65, the overall cognitive test score was slightly higher with beta-carotene after an average of 18 years, while in a separate group of 1904 men aged 65 and older no convincing difference was found at about one year. When choosing a form, note that these are beta-carotene data and do not establish the same effect for retinol. [2] See the evidence 1 2
Practical guide
Check the conclusions and whether they apply to your situation.
The form and source of vitamin A determine conversion of the amount and safety limits.
Key points
Why these conclusions
Forms, units and studies
Preformed vitamin A is retinol and its esters; provitamin A consists of carotenoids, including beta-carotene. Their RAE contribution and safety limits differ. [1]
1 µg RAE corresponds to 1 µg retinol, 2 µg beta-carotene from a supplement or 12 µg beta-carotene from food. State the form and units when comparing labels. [1]
In the United States, the RDA for total intake in adults is 900 µg RAE/day for men and 700 µg RAE/day for women. This is a reference for food and supplements combined, not the dose of a single supplement. [1]
In the United States, the total intake reference for pregnant people aged 19–50 is 770 µg RAE/day and for lactating people 1300 µg RAE/day; these values do not establish a supplement dose. [1]
In the United States, the tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 19 and older is 3000 µg RAE of preformed vitamin A per day from food and supplements combined. It applies to retinol and its esters, not beta-carotene; limits for children are lower. [1]
In beta-carotene supplement trials, lung cancer risk was higher among people who smoked or were exposed to asbestos; CARET also used retinyl palmitate. These results do not apply to vegetables containing carotenoids. [1]
EFSA established a tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 18 and older of 3000 µg RE per day of preformed vitamin A from all sources. Long-term excess retinol and its esters can damage the liver; this level is not a target or a guarantee of individual safety. [1] [3]
In the PHS study, men took 50 mg beta-carotene every other day or placebo. In the long-term group the overall test result was slightly higher after an average of 18 years; in a separate group no convincing difference was found at about one year. Certainty in each result is very low. [2]
Preformed vitamin A is retinol and its esters; provitamin A consists of carotenoids, including beta-carotene. Their RAE contribution and safety limits differ.
Preformed vitamin A is retinol and its esters; provitamin A consists of carotenoids, including beta-carotene. Their RAE contribution and safety limits differ. [1]
1 µg RAE corresponds to 1 µg retinol, 2 µg beta-carotene from a supplement or 12 µg beta-carotene from food. State the form and units when comparing labels.
1 µg RAE corresponds to 1 µg retinol, 2 µg beta-carotene from a supplement or 12 µg beta-carotene from food. State the form and units when comparing labels. [1]
In the United States, the RDA for total intake in adults is 900 µg RAE/day for men and 700 µg RAE/day for women. This is a reference for food and supplements combined, not the dose of a single supplement.
In the United States, the RDA for total intake in adults is 900 µg RAE/day for men and 700 µg RAE/day for women. This is a reference for food and supplements combined, not the dose of a single supplement. [1]
In the United States, the total intake reference for pregnant people aged 19–50 is 770 µg RAE/day and for lactating people 1300 µg RAE/day; these values do not establish a supplement dose.
In the United States, the total intake reference for pregnant people aged 19–50 is 770 µg RAE/day and for lactating people 1300 µg RAE/day; these values do not establish a supplement dose. [1]
In the United States, the tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 19 and older is 3000 µg RAE of preformed vitamin A per day from food and supplements combined. It applies to retinol and its esters, not beta-carotene; limits for children are lower.
In the United States, the tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 19 and older is 3000 µg RAE of preformed vitamin A per day from food and supplements combined. It applies to retinol and its esters, not beta-carotene; limits for children are lower. [1]
In beta-carotene supplement trials, lung cancer risk was higher among people who smoked or were exposed to asbestos; CARET also used retinyl palmitate. These results do not apply to vegetables containing carotenoids.
In beta-carotene supplement trials, lung cancer risk was higher among people who smoked or were exposed to asbestos; CARET also used retinyl palmitate. These results do not apply to vegetables containing carotenoids. [1]
In the beta-carotene group, the overall cognitive test result was higher by 0.047 standardized units.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | In the beta-carotene group, the overall cognitive test result was higher by 0.047 standardized units. Difference 0.047 standardized units, p=0.03. |
| Participants | 4052 men older than 65 previously enrolled in PHS |
| Form | Beta-carotene |
| Dose | 50 mg every other day |
| Dose basis | 50 mg every other day |
| Comparator | Placebo |
| Duration | Average 18 years |
| Confidence | 1/4: Study methods: cognitive assessment in subgroups of a long-term study.; Consistency: no grounds for a separate downgrade.; Applicability to the specified group: a standardized change does not establish a meaningful effect in daily life.; Precision: the interval or amount of data limits conclusions about a clinically meaningful effect.; Possible publication bias: no specific data for a separate downgrade. |
| Evidence base | 1 trial |
| Sources | [2] |
No convincing difference in overall cognitive assessment was found.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | No convincing difference in overall cognitive assessment was found. No convincing difference was found. |
| Participants | 1904 new PHS II participants—men aged 65 and older at cognitive testing |
| Form | Beta-carotene |
| Dose | 50 mg every other day |
| Dose basis | 50 mg every other day |
| Comparator | Placebo |
| Duration | Average about 1 year |
| Confidence | 1/4: Study methods: cognitive assessment in subgroups of a long-term study.; Consistency: no grounds for a separate downgrade.; Applicability to the specified group: a standardized change does not establish a meaningful effect in daily life.; Precision: the interval or amount of data limits conclusions about a clinically meaningful effect.; Possible publication bias: no specific data for a separate downgrade. |
| Evidence base | 1 trial |
| Sources | [2] |
EFSA established a tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 18 and older of 3000 µg RE per day of preformed vitamin A from all sources. Long-term excess retinol and its esters can damage the liver; this level is not a target or a guarantee of individual safety.
EFSA established a tolerable upper intake level for adults aged 18 and older of 3000 µg RE per day of preformed vitamin A from all sources. Long-term excess retinol and its esters can damage the liver; this level is not a target or a guarantee of individual safety. [1] [3]
Sources
- Vitamin A and Carotenoids - Health Professional Fact Sheet. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminA-HealthProfessional/
- A randomized trial of beta carotene supplementation and cognitive function in men: the Physicians' Health Study II. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17998490/
- Scientific opinion on the tolerable upper intake level for preformed vitamin A and β-carotene. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11154838/
Methodology: Subpages evidence-led supplement pipeline v1