Supplement encyclopedia

AMINO ACIDS, ESSENTIAL

Essential amino acids are components of protein that the body must obtain from food; they are also available in supplements.

Check the conclusions and examine the sources before choosing a supplement.

Main conclusion

What it may offer

  • After resistance exercise in young active men, an essential amino acid (EAA) mixture with a higher proportion of leucine produced a strength measure approximately 10% higher on average across measurements over four days than a carbohydrate placebo.
  • In the same trial, the mixture with a higher proportion of leucine did not convincingly reduce muscle soreness.
  • In another small trial in young men after calf exercise, the worst pain during the first day was lower with a different EAA mixture: about 31 points out of 100 versus 65 with placebo.

[1] [2]

What was studied

  • Maximum muscle strength after resistance exercise was studied in young men.
  • Studies in young men assessed how sore their muscles were after exercise.

[1] [2]

Forms considered

  • There are nine essential amino acids; BCAAs are three of them: leucine, isoleucine and valine.
  • The studies used EAA mixtures with different compositions and proportions of leucine; the amount of the whole mixture must be distinguished from the amount of an individual amino acid.

[1] [2] [3] [4]

Getting it from food

  • Essential amino acids come from ordinary protein foods: meat, fish, eggs and dairy products. In 85 g of cooked wild Atlantic salmon, the sum of the nine amino acids is about 9.2 g.
  • Plant foods also contribute: a 164 g cup of cooked salted chickpeas contains about 5.3 g of the nine amino acids combined, and 28.35 g of dry-roasted salted almonds contains about 1.8 g. Food and the mixtures studied differ in composition, so these amounts cannot be treated as an equivalent supplement dose.

[1] [2] [3] [4]

Effects and studied questions

How to read the certainty scale 1–4

Certainty is rated separately for each outcome. 1 is very low, 2 is low, 3 is moderate and 4 is high.

Goal or questionResultConfidenceStudiesPopulation studiedKey sources
Total peak torque during recoveryIn 20 young men, the studied LEAA mixture at 12 g/day for four days produced approximately 10% greater total peak torque during recovery after resistance exercise than placebo.Total peak torque was approximately 10% higher in the LEAA group overall across the recovery period; main effect of group p=0.042, group-by-time interaction not significant.
2/4 LowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.
11 trialLeucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/day
  1. Leucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗
Subjective muscle sorenessIn the same trial, the leucine-enriched EAA mixture showed no convincing difference in muscle soreness versus placebo; the interval for the result at one day included both reduced pain and no benefit.There were no significant group or interaction effects on soreness (p>0.05). For total soreness at 24 hours, Hedges g −0.47 (95% CI −1.38 to 0.40).
2/4 LowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.
11 trialLeucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/day
  1. Leucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗
Worst soreness during the previous day on the NPRS 0–100 scale at 24 hoursIn a small trial of young men, the worst pain one day after eccentric exercise was lower with a particular EAA mixture: 31.4 versus 64.6 points out of 100 with placebo.At 24 hours NPRS Worst was 31.4±11.0 with EAA versus 64.6±24.6 with placebo (0–100 scale); difference p<0.001. This is a separate measure and time point.
1/4 Very lowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.
11 trialEffects of essential amino acid supplementation on musculotendinous recovery following eccentric plantar flexor exercise: a randomized controlled trial ↗Young recreationally active men; 44 enrolled, 36 completed across three groups; the size of each compared group was not separately specified in the main text
  1. Effects of essential amino acid supplementation on musculotendinous recovery following eccentric plantar flexor exercise: a randomized controlled trial ↗

The study count refers to the cited source. Reviews with overlapping trials and outcomes from one study are not added together.

Daily intake requirements and upper limits

Intake and studied regimens
ContextInformation
Intake recommendationsAn ISSN review gives adult requirement estimates for each amino acid from the entire diet, in mg/kg body weight per day: histidine 18; isoleucine 23; leucine 49; lysine 48; methionine 23; phenylalanine 48; threonine 28; tryptophan 8; valine 32. These are not doses of EAA supplements or the total amount of protein.

International society of sports nutrition position stand: essential amino acid supplementation on skeletal muscle and Performance ↗

Intake and studied regimens
ContextInformation
Intake and studied regimensThe trials presented studied specific regimens: 12 g/day LEAA for four days and 10 g EAA servings over 72 hours. These are studied amounts of mixtures, not a single daily requirement for an EAA supplement.

Leucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗
Effects of essential amino acid supplementation on musculotendinous recovery following eccentric plantar flexor exercise: a randomized controlled trial ↗

Forms

EAA are nine essential amino acids: histidine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, methionine, phenylalanine, threonine, tryptophan and valine. They must be obtained from food. BCAAs include only leucine, isoleucine and valine; they are a subset of EAAs. The result for a separate BCAA mixture is not considered a trial of a complete mixture of all nine EAAs. EAA is a class of mixtures with different proportions and added ingredients. In two recovery studies the leucine content was 40% and 19.64%; their results are labeled by the specific composition.

Guidance for each goal

Total peak torque during recovery2/4 LowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
2/4 LowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.

In 20 young men, the studied LEAA mixture at 12 g/day for four days produced approximately 10% greater total peak torque during recovery after resistance exercise than placebo.

Study findings. In 20 young men, the studied LEAA mixture at 12 g/day for four days produced approximately 10% greater total peak torque during recovery after resistance exercise than placebo.

Studied regimen4 g EAA, including 1.6 g leucine, three times daily; 12 g EAA/dayLEAA: mixture of nine crystalline EAAs with 40% leucine, Waskiw-Ford 2020 study
Duration and population96 hours after resistance exercise20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/day

Comparison with isocaloric Polycal carbohydrate placebo; identical flavorings

Subjective muscle soreness2/4 LowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
2/4 LowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.

In the same trial, the leucine-enriched EAA mixture showed no convincing difference in muscle soreness versus placebo; the interval for the result at one day included both reduced pain and no benefit.

Study findings. In the same trial, the leucine-enriched EAA mixture showed no convincing difference in muscle soreness versus placebo; the interval for the result at one day included both reduced pain and no benefit.

Studied regimen4 g EAA, including 1.6 g leucine, three times daily; 12 g EAA/dayLEAA: mixture of nine crystalline EAAs with 40% leucine, Waskiw-Ford 2020 study
Duration and population96 hours after resistance exercise20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/day

Comparison with isocaloric Polycal carbohydrate placebo; identical flavorings

Worst soreness during the previous day on the NPRS 0–100 scale at 24 hours1/4 Very lowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
1/4 Very lowPrecision: Small sample, limited events or effect interval Consistency of results: Single study: heterogeneity cannot be assessed. Applicability to the specified group: The assessment is limited to the specified product and population. Possible publication bias: Insufficient grounds for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small samples, participant dropouts, multiple outcomes or incomplete description of allocation and the protocol of this trial.

In a small trial of young men, the worst pain one day after eccentric exercise was lower with a particular EAA mixture: 31.4 versus 64.6 points out of 100 with placebo.

Study findings. In a small trial of young men, the worst pain one day after eccentric exercise was lower with a particular EAA mixture: 31.4 versus 64.6 points out of 100 with placebo.

Studied regimen10 g each 30 minutes before and immediately after exercise; two servings each on the next two days and one before the 72-hour assessmentOptimal Labs LLC EAA product with 19.64% leucine
Duration and population72 hours after eccentric calf muscle exerciseYoung recreationally active men; 44 enrolled, 36 completed across three groups; the size of each compared group was not separately specified in the main text

Comparison with 10 g maltodextrin per serving; separate no-supplement group

Safety and limitations

Complete EAA mixtures contain phenylalanine. In phenylketonuria, its amount is restricted in a specially tailored diet; a standard complete EAA mixture requires its composition to be checked by a specialist. In maple syrup urine disease, BCAA metabolism is impaired. Mixtures containing leucine, isoleucine and valine require special selection, including complete EAA products. With impaired kidney function, protein and amino acid amounts are tailored to the disease. There are insufficient data to extrapolate the safety of free-form EAA mixtures to this group. Limits for individual amino acids from small studies are not added together to form a universal safe limit for any EAA mixture. Composition, overall diet and duration of use are considered separately.

Phenylketonuria — MedlinePlus Genetics ↗ · Maple syrup urine disease — MedlinePlus Genetics ↗ · International society of sports nutrition position stand: essential amino acid supplementation on skeletal muscle and Performance ↗

Food sources

The sum of the nine amino acids in food is shown, including those bound in protein: this is not total protein, BCAAs alone or the mass of a free-form supplement.

Meat and organ meats

Meat and liver contain essential amino acids as part of protein.

Protein in diet — MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia ↗

Fish, eggs and dairy products

Fish, eggs, milk and yogurt provide dietary protein with essential amino acids.

Protein in diet — MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia ↗

Legumes and soy products

Legumes and soy products provide plant protein and essential amino acids; different plant foods can complement the diet.

Protein in diet — MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia ↗

Nuts, seeds and grains

Nuts, seeds and grains also contribute essential amino acids; their proportions depend on the food.

Protein in diet — MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia ↗

Food composition

FoodGroupAmountServingCaloriesSources
Beef liverpan-friedMeat and organ meats11.641 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g81 g · 9.42921 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 141.75 kcal1 slice, 81 g; original USDA measure.175 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 13 ↗
Pork loinmeat and fat, cooked by dry heatMeat11.793 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g85 g · 10.02405 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 205.7 kcal3 ounces, 85 g; original USDA measure.242 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 10 ↗
Wild Atlantic salmoncooked by dry heatFish10.78 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g85 g · 9.163 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 154.7 kcal3 ounces, 85 g; original USDA measure.182 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 15 ↗
Greek yogurtplain, low-fatDairy products2.537 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g200 g · 5.074 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 146 kcal1 container, 200 g; original USDA measure.73 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 01 ↗
Chickpeasmature seeds, cooked with saltLegumes3.225 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g164 g · 5.289 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 268.96 kcal1 cup, 164 g; original USDA measure.164 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 16 ↗
Almondsdry-roasted, saltedNuts6.232 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g28.35 g · 1.766772 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 169.533 kcal1 ounce, 28.35 g; original USDA measure.598 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 12 ↗
Oatmealunfortified flakes, cooked in water without saltGrains1.005 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) / 100 g234 g · 2.3517 g of nine essential amino acids (sum) · 166.14 kcal1 cup, 234 g; original USDA measure.71 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) — Food Group 08 ↗

Studies

PublicationWhat was studiedParticipantsForm and doseResult
Leucine-Enriched Essential Amino Acids Improve Recovery from Post-Exercise Muscle Damage Independent of Increases in Integrated Myofibrillar Protein Synthesis in Young Men ↗randomized controlled trialTotal peak torque during recovery: Total peak torque during recovery Subjective muscle soreness: Subjective muscle sorenessTotal peak torque during recovery: 20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/day Subjective muscle soreness: 20 healthy recreationally active men; 10 in each group; dietary protein approximately 1.2 g/kg/dayTotal peak torque during recovery: LEAA: mixture of nine crystalline EAAs with 40% leucine, Waskiw-Ford 2020 study; 4 g EAA, including 1.6 g leucine, three times daily; 12 g EAA/day; 96 hours after resistance exercise; comparison: Isocaloric Polycal carbohydrate placebo; identical flavorings Subjective muscle soreness: LEAA: mixture of nine crystalline EAAs with 40% leucine, Waskiw-Ford 2020 study; 4 g EAA, including 1.6 g leucine, three times daily; 12 g EAA/day; 96 hours after resistance exercise; comparison: Isocaloric Polycal carbohydrate placebo; identical flavoringsTotal peak torque during recovery: In 20 young men, the studied LEAA mixture at 12 g/day for four days produced approximately 10% greater total peak torque during recovery after resistance exercise than placebo. Subjective muscle soreness: In the same trial, the leucine-enriched EAA mixture showed no convincing difference in muscle soreness versus placebo; the interval for the result at one day included both reduced pain and no benefit.
Effects of essential amino acid supplementation on musculotendinous recovery following eccentric plantar flexor exercise: a randomized controlled trial ↗randomized controlled trialWorst soreness during the previous day on the NPRS 0–100 scale at 24 hoursYoung recreationally active men; 44 enrolled, 36 completed across three groups; the size of each compared group was not separately specified in the main textOptimal Labs LLC EAA product with 19.64% leucine; 10 g each 30 minutes before and immediately after exercise; two servings each on the next two days and one before the 72-hour assessment; 72 hours after eccentric calf muscle exercise; comparison: 10 g maltodextrin per serving; separate no-supplement groupIn a small trial of young men, the worst pain one day after eccentric exercise was lower with a particular EAA mixture: 31.4 versus 64.6 points out of 100 with placebo.