Turmeric and knee pain when walking
WDTE60N study in adults with chronic knee pain without arthritis.
Key points
- In adults with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis, pain after brisk walking decreased about 0.9 points out of 10 more with WDTE60N than placebo over 90 days. For this group and product there is a preliminary signal of less pain after walking. [1] See the evidence 1
- The authors of the same study reported a greater reduction in time for a brisk 80-meter walk with WDTE60N, but the table had an unusual relationship between means and medians. Consider this uncertainty when assessing the walking result. [1] See the evidence 1
Practical guide
Check the conclusions and whether they apply to your situation.
The study assessed pain and brisk walking time separately.
Key points
Why these conclusions
The WDTE60N study
Adults aged 18–60 with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis received 250 mg WDTE60N daily, including 150 mg curcuminoids, or placebo for 90 days. Pain after brisk walking decreased about 0.9 points out of 10 more with the extract. [1]
The authors reported a greater reduction in time for a brisk 80 m walk with WDTE60N. The table has an unusual relationship between means and medians, so the time result remains uncertain. [1]
TGA warns of rare, sometimes severe liver injury from turmeric or curcumin supplements. Risk may be higher with enhanced-absorption supplements or high doses. Stop and seek medical help for jaundice, dark urine or unusual weakness; avoid such supplements with current or past liver disease. [2]
In adults with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis, pain after brisk walking decreased about 0.9 points out of 10 more with WDTE60N than placebo.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | In adults with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis, pain after brisk walking decreased about 0.9 points out of 10 more with WDTE60N than placebo. Change −1.5±0.7 versus −0.6±0.8 points out of 10, p<0.0001; approximate difference −0.9 points. |
| Participants | 106 adults aged 18–60 with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis; 49 and 47 completed |
| Form | Oral water-dispersible extract WDTE60N |
| Dose | 250 mg/day, 150 mg curcuminoids |
| Dose basis | 250 mg/day, 150 mg curcuminoids |
| Comparator | Placebo, rescue analgesics permitted |
| Duration | 90 days |
| Confidence | 2/4: Precision: Exact confidence interval for the difference unavailable. Consistency: No grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the specified group: Measurement directly addresses the specified narrow PICO. Possible publication bias: No specific data for a separate downgrade. Study methods: 10 of 106 dropped out; sponsored study. |
| Evidence base | 1 randomized trial |
| Sources | [1] |
According to the authors, time for a brisk 80-meter walk decreased more with WDTE60N than placebo; the table shows an unusual relationship between means and medians.
| Parameter | Data |
|---|---|
| Result | According to the authors, time for a brisk 80-meter walk decreased more with WDTE60N than placebo; the table shows an unusual relationship between means and medians. Changes −11.0±26.1 versus −6.8±23.3 s, p=0.0011 as reported; distributions and table show an unusual relationship between means and medians. |
| Participants | 106 adults with chronic knee pain without radiographic arthritis, 49 and 47 completed |
| Form | Oral WDTE60N, 150 mg curcuminoids |
| Dose | 250 mg/day |
| Dose basis | 250 mg/day |
| Comparator | placebo |
| Duration | 90 days |
| Confidence | 1/4: Precision: Confidence interval for the direct contrast was not extracted or concerns group means. Consistency: No grounds for a separate downgrade. Applicability to the specified group: Exact protocol and specific formula. Possible publication bias: No specific data for a separate downgrade. Study methods: Small groups, multiple outcomes or completer analysis. |
| Evidence base | 1 randomized trial |
| Sources | [1] |
TGA warns of rare, sometimes severe liver injury from turmeric or curcumin supplements. Risk may be higher with enhanced-absorption supplements or high doses. Stop and seek medical help for jaundice, dark urine or unusual weakness; avoid such supplements with current or past liver disease.
TGA warns of rare, sometimes severe liver injury from turmeric or curcumin supplements. Risk may be higher with enhanced-absorption supplements or high doses. Stop and seek medical help for jaundice, dark urine or unusual weakness; avoid such supplements with current or past liver disease. [2]
More details
Which group the results apply to
Results apply to participants with chronic knee pain without arthritis detected on X-ray and the specific WDTE60N formula. [1]
Sources
- A Multicenter, Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial Assessing Efficacy and Safety of a Novel Low-Dose Turmeric Extract Formulation in Healthy Adults with Chronic Knee Pain. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8149286/
- TGA Medicines containing turmeric or curcumin - risk of liver injury. https://www.tga.gov.au/safety/safety-monitoring-and-information/safety-alerts/medicines-containing-turmeric-or-curcumin-risk-liver-injury
Methodology: Subpages evidence-led supplement pipeline v1