Calcium: cramps and muscle strength

Results of studies of calcium for cramps and strength tests in adults.

Key points

  • In healthy men aged 40 and over, calcium citrate showed no clear advantage over placebo for cramps or change in grip strength over two years. Cramps were assessed by recall over the previous six months. [1] See the evidence 1 2
  • In women doing resistance training, maximal squat strength increased by 5.62 kg more with amorphous calcium carbonate than placebo, but analysis of changes over time did not confirm a sustained difference. No clear advantage was found for bench press. [2] See the evidence 1 2

Practical guide

Check the conclusions and whether they apply to your situation.

The studies assessed different groups and separate measures of muscle function.

Key points

Why these conclusions

Cramps and strength tests

Healthy men aged 40 and over without osteoporosis took 600 or 1,200 mg elemental calcium as citrate or placebo for two years. At the visit, cramps in the previous six months were reported by 43%, 51% and 47% respectively; grip strength also did not differ clearly. Certainty low, 2 out of 4. [1]

Women in resistance training took 1,000 mg amorphous calcium carbonate as a compound daily or placebo for nine weeks. The 5.62 kg difference in squat gain was not accompanied by a sustained difference in the analysis over time; no clear advantage was found for bench press. Certainty very low, 1 out of 4. [2]

At the two-year visit, cramps in the preceding six months were reported by 47% of men on placebo, 43% on 600 mg and 51% on 1,200 mg calcium daily. No clear difference between groups was found (p=0.58).

ParameterData
ResultAt the two-year visit, cramps in the preceding six months were reported by 47% of men on placebo, 43% on 600 mg and 51% on 1,200 mg calcium daily. No clear difference between groups was found (p=0.58).
Participants323 healthy men aged 40 and over without osteoporosis, 107 placebo and 108 in each calcium group
FormCalcium citrate
Dose600 or 1,200 mg elemental calcium/day
Dose basis600 or 1,200 mg elemental calcium/day
ComparatorPlacebo
Duration2 years of intake; at the two-year visit cramps in the preceding 6 months were asked about
Confidence2/4: Precision: The CI for the contrast was not reported.; Consistency: No significant between-study inconsistency for the conclusion was established or the estimate is from one study.; Applicability to the specified group: The conclusion is limited to the directly studied outcome and population.; Possible publication bias: No grounds for a separate downgrade.; Study methods: Secondary outcome, cramps assessed by questionnaire.
Evidence base1 trial
Sources[1]

Over two years, no clear difference in change in grip strength between calcium citrate and placebo was found in healthy men aged 40 and over without osteoporosis.

ParameterData
ResultOver two years, no clear difference in change in grip strength between calcium citrate and placebo was found in healthy men aged 40 and over without osteoporosis.
Participants323 healthy men aged 40 and over without osteoporosis, 107 placebo and 108 in each calcium group
FormCalcium citrate
Dose600 or 1,200 mg elemental calcium/day
Dose basis600 or 1,200 mg elemental calcium/day
ComparatorPlacebo
Duration2 years
Confidence2/4: Precision: The CI for the contrast was not reported.; Consistency: No significant between-study inconsistency for the conclusion was established or the estimate is from one study.; Applicability to the specified group: The conclusion is limited to the directly studied outcome and population.; Possible publication bias: No grounds for a separate downgrade.; Study methods: Secondary outcome, cramps assessed by questionnaire.
Evidence base1 trial
Sources[1]

In one study, maximal squat strength increased 5.62 kg more with amorphous calcium carbonate than placebo. Analysis of changes over time between groups did not confirm a sustained difference.

ParameterData
ResultIn one study, maximal squat strength increased 5.62 kg more with amorphous calcium carbonate than placebo. Analysis of changes over time between groups did not confirm a sustained difference.
Participants31 women doing resistance training
FormAmorphous calcium carbonate
Dose1,000 mg of compound/day
Dose basis1,000 mg of compound/day
ComparatorPlacebo, same training context
Duration9 weeks
Confidence1/4: Precision: 31 participants, no exact interval for the interaction.; Consistency: No significant between-study inconsistency for the conclusion was established or the estimate is from one study.; Applicability to the specified group: The conclusion is limited to the directly studied outcome and population.; Possible publication bias: No grounds for a separate downgrade.; Study methods: Several related outcomes and methods of analysis.
Evidence base1 trial
Sources[2]

In one study of women in training, no clear advantage of amorphous calcium carbonate over placebo was found for bench-press strength.

ParameterData
ResultIn one study of women in training, no clear advantage of amorphous calcium carbonate over placebo was found for bench-press strength.
Participants31 women doing resistance training
FormAmorphous calcium carbonate
Dose1,000 mg of compound/day
Dose basis1,000 mg of compound/day
ComparatorPlacebo, same training context
Duration9 weeks
Confidence1/4: Precision: 31 participants, no exact interval for the interaction.; Consistency: No significant between-study inconsistency for the conclusion was established or the estimate is from one study.; Applicability to the specified group: The conclusion is limited to the directly studied outcome and population.; Possible publication bias: No grounds for a separate downgrade.; Study methods: Several related outcomes and methods of analysis.
Evidence base1 trial
Sources[2]

More details

What was measured

The study of men assessed cramps and grip strength, while the study of women assessed specific strength exercises. The carbonate dose is given as compound mass. [1] [2]

Sources

  1. Randomized Controlled Trial of Calcium Supplementation in Healthy, Nonosteoporotic, Older Men. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/414616
  2. The Effects of Amorphous Calcium Carbonate (ACC) Supplementation on Resistance Exercise Performance in Women. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9919417/

Methodology: Subpages evidence-led supplement pipeline v1

Ingredient overview: Calcium