Supplement encyclopedia

Beta carotene

Beta-carotene is a plant pigment that the body uses to make vitamin A. It is found in carrots, sweet potatoes, pumpkin, and leafy greens. Supplement studies looked at skin condition and memory test scores. These are separate questions from whether beta-carotene helps meet vitamin A needs.

Double-check the conclusions and review the sources before choosing a supplement.

Main conclusion

Potential benefits

  • The body converts some beta-carotene from food into vitamin A, which is needed for normal vision and immune system function.
  • In male physicians over 65, scores on word-memory tasks and a general memory and thinking test were slightly higher after about 18 years of beta-carotene use than with placebo. In one general test, the difference was 0.18 points out of 41.
  • After about a year of use, another group of male physicians showed no advantage in the overall memory and thinking test result.
  • In female health workers aged 65 and over with cardiovascular disease or at least three risk factors for it, no convincing difference in changes in memory test results was found during follow-up.
  • In adults under 55 in another trial, daily beta-carotene use for 4.5 years showed no convincing slowing of skin aging on the back of the hand.

[1] [2] [3] [4] [5]

What was studied

  • In a review of small studies, skin redness after ultraviolet exposure was less after taking beta-carotene products and carotenoid mixtures. Beta-carotene does not replace sunscreen.
  • People who smoke should avoid beta-carotene supplements: in a large trial, 20 mg daily for 5–8 years increased lung cancer incidence by 18% relative to the group without beta-carotene.
  • Former smokers and people with occupational asbestos exposure should also consider the risk: in a trial, beta-carotene combined with preformed vitamin A increased lung cancer risk.

[1] [2] [3] [4]

Forms studied

  • Memory studies used 50 mg of beta-carotene every other day: for about a year or an average of 18 years in men, and an average of 8.9 years in women.
  • For skin, researchers studied beta-carotene tablets and algae extracts containing carotenoid mixtures. For example, 25 mg of one mixture contained 23.8 mg of beta-carotene; check the label for the amount of beta-carotene itself.
  • In combination supplements, preformed vitamin A, retinol or its esters, is listed separately from beta-carotene. During pregnancy and when planning it, checking for retinol is particularly important: excess retinol may harm the child’s development.

[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]

How to get it from food

  • A medium raw carrot weighing 61 g contains about 5.1 mg of beta-carotene; the baked flesh of a medium sweet potato without salt weighing 114 g contains about 13.1 mg.
  • A 122.5 g portion of canned pumpkin without salt contains about 8.5 mg of beta-carotene, and a cup of raw spinach weighing 30 g about 1.7 mg.
  • A cup of fresh cantaloupe cubes weighing 160 g contains about 3.2 mg of beta-carotene. These values refer to the pigment itself.

[1]

Effects and studied questions

How to read the certainty scale 1–4

Certainty is rated separately for each outcome. 1 is very low, 2 is low, 3 is moderate and 4 is high.

Goal or questionResultConfidenceStudiesPopulation studiedKey sources
Skin redness after UV exposureThe review pooled results from 7 studies and found less redness, with a difference of 0.80 standard deviations (95% CI 0.20–1.40). This value is on a common statistical scale and cannot be read as a percentage of protection. The analysis included different blends and before-and-after comparisons, so it cannot give a precise estimate of the effect of pure beta-carotene.
1/4 Very lowConfidence is very low because the review pooled different formulations and comparison methods, including measurements taken before and after supplementation in the same participants. The studies measured redness in small areas of skin. The result does not establish an SPF for the supplement or show whether it protects the skin during everyday sun exposure. The results depended on which measurement was selected from one study. The pooled analysis cannot reliably establish how soon an effect appears.
1review (7 included studies)Protection from sunburn with beta-Carotene--a meta-analysis ↗Participants in 7 small studies. The Stahl and Heinrich studies involved healthy, fair-skinned adults aged 20–57 and 22–55, respectively.
  1. Protection from sunburn with beta-Carotene--a meta-analysis ↗
Skin aging on the back of the handBeta-carotene did not slow skin aging on the back of the hand. The odds ratio for worsening of the skin rating was 0.95 (95% CI 0.74–1.22, p=0.69). Sunscreen was studied separately in the same trial.
2/4 LowConfidence is low. The supplement was compared with placebo, and the skin impressions were rated without knowledge of treatment assignment. Some participants did not have skin impressions from both years. The interval for the estimate is compatible with either a slight slowing or an acceleration of skin aging. The trial assessed the skin surface of the hand. The result does not describe all types of wrinkles or the condition of facial skin.
1randomized trialSunscreen and prevention of skin aging: a randomized trial ↗903 Australian residents younger than 55. Usable skin impressions were available for 886, and 604 had both measurements.
  1. Sunscreen and prevention of skin aging: a randomized trial ↗
Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementationThe average score on the telephone-based TICS test was 34.41 with the supplement and 34.23 with placebo, a difference of +0.18 points out of 41 (95% CI 0.01–0.35). This was a small difference after many years of supplementation.
3/4 ModerateConfidence is moderate. This was a large randomized comparison, and memory was tested without knowledge of treatment assignment. The difference was very small. Testing at the end of supplementation cannot show how much each person's memory changed over 18 years. The participants were male physicians older than 65. The result cannot be generalized to women, younger people, or short-term use.
2publications from a single randomized trialA randomized trial of beta carotene supplementation and cognitive function in men: the Physicians' Health Study II ↗4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group
  1. A randomized trial of beta carotene supplementation and cognitive function in men: the Physicians' Health Study II ↗
  2. Vitamin and mineral supplementation for maintaining cognitive function in cognitively healthy people in mid and late life ↗

The study count refers to the cited source. Reviews with overlapping trials and outcomes from one study are not added together.

Daily intake requirements and upper limits

Vitamin A: Total daily intake from food and supplements in the US
Groupµg RAE/dayType of reference value
0–6 months400AI (Adequate Intake)
7–12 months500AI (Adequate Intake)
1–3 years300RDA
4–8 years400RDA
9–13 years600RDA
Boys aged 14–18 and men aged 19+900RDA
Girls aged 14–18 and women aged 19+700RDA
Pregnancy, ages 14–18 / 19+750 / 770RDA
Breastfeeding, ages 14–18 / 19+1200 / 1300RDA

Vitamin A and Carotenoids — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals ↗

Units and upper limits in the US
MeasureWhat it means
1 µg RAE1 µg of retinol, 2 µg of beta-carotene from supplements, or 12 µg of beta-carotene from food. These amounts have equivalent vitamin A activity despite differing in mass.
Tolerable Upper Intake Level (UL) for preformed vitamin AIn µg RAE/day, the limits are 600 up to age 3, 900 for ages 4–8, 1,700 for ages 9–13, 2,800 for ages 14–18, and 3,000 for ages 19 and older. Retinol and its esters from all food and supplements count toward these limits.
Beta-caroteneNo separate safe upper limit has been established. The limit for retinol cannot be applied to beta-carotene.
RDA and AIRDA stands for Recommended Dietary Allowance. AI stands for Adequate Intake and is used when there is insufficient evidence to set an RDA. Both values apply to total vitamin A intake from food and supplements and do not specify a supplement dose.

Vitamin A and Carotenoids — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals ↗

EFSA's approach to beta-carotene supplements, 2024
TopicWhat it means
Purpose of useEFSA limits the use of beta-carotene in supplements and fortified foods to meeting vitamin A needs.
SmokingEFSA recommends that people who smoke avoid beta-carotene supplements.
Upper limitEFSA could not establish an upper limit for beta-carotene itself and retained the adult limit of 3,000 µg RE/day for preformed vitamin A. RE and RAE use different systems for converting carotenoids to vitamin A equivalents.

Scientific opinion on the tolerable upper intake level for preformed vitamin A and β‐carotene ↗

Forms

Beta-carotene. The memory studies used 50 mg every other day, and the skin aging study used 30 mg tablets daily. These dosing schedules apply to the specific trials. Algae extracts. The studies on skin redness used extracts including Dunaliella salina. In Stahl's preparation, 25 mg of the blend contained 23.8 mg of beta-carotene, with other carotenoids making up the remainder. Heinrich's preparation contained about 24 mg of beta-carotene and small amounts of other carotenoids. Check the label for the composition of the blend. Blends containing preformed vitamin A. Retinol and retinyl esters are counted separately from beta-carotene. They have their own upper limit. Conversion to vitamin A. In the US system, 1 µg RAE corresponds to 2 µg of beta-carotene from supplements or 12 µg from food. This standard conversion expresses vitamin A activity and cannot predict how much an individual will absorb.

Guidance for each goal

Skin redness after UV exposure1/4 Very lowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
1/4 Very lowConfidence is very low because the review pooled different formulations and comparison methods, including measurements taken before and after supplementation in the same participants. The studies measured redness in small areas of skin. The result does not establish an SPF for the supplement or show whether it protects the skin during everyday sun exposure. The results depended on which measurement was selected from one study. The pooled analysis cannot reliably establish how soon an effect appears.

The review pooled results from 7 studies and found less redness, with a difference of 0.80 standard deviations (95% CI 0.20–1.40). This value is on a common statistical scale and cannot be read as a percentage of protection. The analysis included different blends and before-and-after comparisons, so it cannot give a precise estimate of the effect of pure beta-carotene.

Study findings. The review pooled results from 7 studies and found less redness, with a difference of 0.80 standard deviations (95% CI 0.20–1.40). This value is on a common statistical scale and cannot be read as a percentage of protection. The analysis included different blends and before-and-after comparisons, so it cannot give a precise estimate of the effect of pure beta-carotene.

Studied regimenThe review table lists 15–180 mg/day, with some values referring to the whole blend. In Lee's study, participants took 30, 60, and 90 mg of the blend, equivalent to 29.4, 58.8, and 88.2 mg of beta-carotene, in successive 8-week periods.Beta-carotene and algae extracts containing beta-carotene and other carotenoids
Duration and population3–24 weeksParticipants in 7 small studies. The Stahl and Heinrich studies involved healthy, fair-skinned adults aged 20–57 and 22–55, respectively.

Comparator: Studies used either placebo or the same participants' skin condition before supplementation as the comparator

Skin aging on the back of the hand2/4 LowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
2/4 LowConfidence is low. The supplement was compared with placebo, and the skin impressions were rated without knowledge of treatment assignment. Some participants did not have skin impressions from both years. The interval for the estimate is compatible with either a slight slowing or an acceleration of skin aging. The trial assessed the skin surface of the hand. The result does not describe all types of wrinkles or the condition of facial skin.

Beta-carotene did not slow skin aging on the back of the hand. The odds ratio for worsening of the skin rating was 0.95 (95% CI 0.74–1.22, p=0.69). Sunscreen was studied separately in the same trial.

Study findings. Beta-carotene did not slow skin aging on the back of the hand. The odds ratio for worsening of the skin rating was 0.95 (95% CI 0.74–1.22, p=0.69). Sunscreen was studied separately in the same trial.

Studied regimen30 mg/dayBeta-carotene tablets
Duration and population4.5 years903 Australian residents younger than 55. Usable skin impressions were available for 886, and 604 had both measurements.

Comparator: Placebo tablets. Assignment to daily or usual sunscreen use was accounted for separately.

Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation3/4 ModerateRead moreCollapse
Confidence
3/4 ModerateConfidence is moderate. This was a large randomized comparison, and memory was tested without knowledge of treatment assignment. The difference was very small. Testing at the end of supplementation cannot show how much each person's memory changed over 18 years. The participants were male physicians older than 65. The result cannot be generalized to women, younger people, or short-term use.

The average score on the telephone-based TICS test was 34.41 with the supplement and 34.23 with placebo, a difference of +0.18 points out of 41 (95% CI 0.01–0.35). This was a small difference after many years of supplementation.

Study findings. The average score on the telephone-based TICS test was 34.41 with the supplement and 34.23 with placebo, a difference of +0.18 points out of 41 (95% CI 0.01–0.35). This was a small difference after many years of supplementation.

Studied regimen50 mg every other dayLurotin beta-carotene, taken orally
Duration and populationAn average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group

Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.

Changes in memory and thinking in older women2/4 LowRead moreCollapse
Confidence
2/4 LowConfidence is low. This was a large placebo comparison with repeated memory assessments, but some participants did not complete all four assessments. The confidence interval includes no difference. This group consisted specifically of women with cardiovascular disease or risk factors for it.

The study did not detect a difference in the change in the overall test score. The estimate was +0.03 standardized units in favor of the supplement (95% CI −0.02 to 0.07, p=0.28). The estimate compares changes over the follow-up period rather than gains per year.

Study findings. The study did not detect a difference in the change in the overall test score. The estimate was +0.03 standardized units in favor of the supplement (95% CI −0.02 to 0.07, p=0.28). The estimate compares changes over the follow-up period rather than gains per year.

Studied regimen50 mg every other dayBeta-carotene, taken orally
Duration and populationAn average of 8.9 years of supplementation. Four memory assessments over 5.4 years, with the first after 3.5 years of supplementation.2,824 female health professionals aged 65 or older with cardiovascular disease or at least three risk factors for it, with 1,406 in the supplement group and 1,418 in the placebo group

Comparator: Placebo. Vitamin C and vitamin E were assigned separately.

Combined score across multiple tests in men after long-term supplementation3/4 ModerateRead moreCollapse
Confidence
3/4 ModerateConfidence is moderate. This was a large randomized comparison, and memory was tested without knowledge of treatment assignment. The difference was very small. Testing at the end of supplementation cannot show how much each person's memory changed over 18 years. The participants were male physicians older than 65. The result cannot be generalized to women, younger people, or short-term use.

The combined score across five tests was 0.047 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.00–0.09, p=0.03). This is a very small difference on the common test scale and cannot be interpreted as the proportion of memory regained.

Study findings. The combined score across five tests was 0.047 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.00–0.09, p=0.03). This is a very small difference on the common test scale and cannot be interpreted as the proportion of memory regained.

Studied regimen50 mg every other dayLurotin beta-carotene, taken orally
Duration and populationAn average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group

Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.

Memory for words and a story in men after long-term supplementation3/4 ModerateRead moreCollapse
Confidence
3/4 ModerateConfidence is moderate. This was a large randomized comparison, and memory was tested without knowledge of treatment assignment. The difference was very small. Testing at the end of supplementation cannot show how much each person's memory changed over 18 years. The participants were male physicians older than 65. The result cannot be generalized to women, younger people, or short-term use.

The overall verbal memory score was 0.063 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.02–0.11, p=0.007). The score combined four tasks involving memorization and recall.

Study findings. The overall verbal memory score was 0.063 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.02–0.11, p=0.007). The score combined four tasks involving memorization and recall.

Studied regimen50 mg every other dayLurotin beta-carotene, taken orally
Duration and populationAn average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group

Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.

Memory and thinking in men after short-term supplementation3/4 ModerateRead moreCollapse
Confidence
3/4 ModerateConfidence is moderate. The trial used a randomized placebo comparison, and memory was tested without knowledge of treatment assignment. The confidence interval allows for a small difference in either direction. This result comes from about a year of supplementation in older men.

The supplement showed no advantage on the overall test score. The difference was −0.014 standardized units (95% CI −0.07 to 0.05, p=0.65).

Study findings. The supplement showed no advantage on the overall test score. The difference was −0.014 standardized units (95% CI −0.07 to 0.05, p=0.65).

Studied regimen50 mg every other dayLurotin beta-carotene, taken orally
Duration and populationAn average of 1 year1,904 male physicians older than 65, with 936 in the beta-carotene group and 968 in the placebo group

Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.

Safety and limitations

People who smoke should avoid beta-carotene supplements. In the ATBC trial of 29,133 men who smoked, taking 20 mg/day for 5–8 years increased lung cancer incidence by 18% relative to the group that did not receive beta-carotene. This was an 18% relative increase in risk. The risk did not rise by 18 percentage points. Former smokers and people exposed to asbestos at work should also consider the risk when choosing a supplement. In CARET, a daily combination of 30 mg of beta-carotene and 7,500 µg RAE of retinyl palmitate increased lung cancer risk. In AREDS2, most new lung cancer cases among participants receiving beta-carotene occurred in former smokers. These findings do not call for avoiding vegetables that contain beta-carotene. Prolonged excessive intake of beta-carotene can give the skin a yellow-orange tint. This known, reversible change in skin color resolves once the excess intake stops. If you are pregnant or planning a pregnancy, check whether the supplement contains retinol or its esters. Excess preformed vitamin A can cause birth defects. This effect has not been established for beta-carotene, but that does not justify taking high doses. EFSA also recommends avoiding liver and liver products during pregnancy and when planning a pregnancy. Beta-carotene cannot replace sunscreen or other forms of sun protection. Reduced redness in small studies does not establish reliable protection against sunburn.

Protection from sunburn with beta-Carotene--a meta-analysis ↗ · Vitamin A and Carotenoids — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals ↗ · Scientific opinion on the tolerable upper intake level for preformed vitamin A and β‐carotene ↗ · The effect of vitamin E and beta carotene on the incidence of lung cancer and other cancers in male smokers ↗

Interactions

WithEffectActionSource
OrlistatOrlistat reduces the absorption of fat-soluble substances, including beta-carotene.If you take orlistat, check the medication instructions and ask your doctor which vitamin supplement to take and when to take it.Vitamin A and Carotenoids — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals ↗
Retinoids and retinol supplementsTaking retinoid medications together with preformed vitamin A supplements increases the risk of excess vitamin A. Check how much retinol and retinyl esters the combination product contains.Clear these combinations with the prescribing doctor. The risk from preformed vitamin A should not be attributed to the amount of beta-carotene alone.Vitamin A and Carotenoids — Fact Sheet for Health Professionals ↗

Food sources

The table gives the beta-carotene content of each food in the stated form or preparation, using USDA SR28 data. 1,000 µg = 1 mg. Each serving shows the amount in food. It cannot be used as an equivalent supplement dose, since the US uses a different conversion factor for vitamin A from dietary beta-carotene.

Food composition

FoodGroupAmountServingCaloriesSources
Sweet potatoBaked flesh without saltVegetables11509 µg / 100 gOne medium sweet potato. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.114 g · 13120.26 µg · 102.6 kcal90 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
CarrotRawVegetables8285 µg / 100 gOne medium carrot. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.61 g · 5053.85 µg · 25.01 kcal41 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
PumpkinCanned without saltVegetables6940 µg / 100 gHalf a cup. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.122.5 g · 8501.5 µg · 41.65 kcal34 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
KaleRawLeafy greens5927 µg / 100 gOne loosely packed cup, 16 g, with pieces about 2.5 cm across.16 g · 948.32 µg · 7.84 kcal49 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
SpinachRawLeafy greens5626 µg / 100 gOne cup. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.30 g · 1687.8 µg · 6.9 kcal23 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
CantaloupeFreshFruit2020 µg / 100 gOne cup of cubes, 160 g.160 g · 3232 µg · 54.4 kcal34 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
ApricotsFreshFruit1094 µg / 100 gOne fruit. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.35 g · 382.9 µg · 16.8 kcal48 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗
BroccoliBoiled without saltVegetables929 µg / 100 gHalf a cup. The amount refers specifically to beta-carotene.78 g · 724.62 µg · 27.3 kcal35 kcal / 100 gUSDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗

USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (2015) ↗

Studies

PublicationWhat was studiedParticipantsForm and doseResult
Protection from sunburn with beta-Carotene--a meta-analysis ↗Skin redness after UV exposureParticipants in 7 small studies. The Stahl and Heinrich studies involved healthy, fair-skinned adults aged 20–57 and 22–55, respectively.Beta-carotene and algae extracts containing beta-carotene and other carotenoids. The review table lists 15–180 mg/day, with some values referring to the whole blend. In Lee's study, participants took 30, 60, and 90 mg of the blend, equivalent to 29.4, 58.8, and 88.2 mg of beta-carotene, in successive 8-week periods. Duration: 3–24 weeks. Comparator: Studies used either placebo or the same participants' skin condition before supplementation as the comparator.The review pooled results from 7 studies and found less redness, with a difference of 0.80 standard deviations (95% CI 0.20–1.40). This value is on a common statistical scale and cannot be read as a percentage of protection. The analysis included different blends and before-and-after comparisons, so it cannot give a precise estimate of the effect of pure beta-carotene.
Sunscreen and prevention of skin aging: a randomized trial ↗Skin aging on the back of the hand903 Australian residents younger than 55. Usable skin impressions were available for 886, and 604 had both measurements.Beta-carotene tablets, 30 mg/day for 4.5 years. Comparator: Placebo tablets. Assignment to daily or usual sunscreen use was accounted for separately.Beta-carotene did not slow skin aging on the back of the hand. The odds ratio for worsening of the skin rating was 0.95 (95% CI 0.74–1.22, p=0.69). Sunscreen was studied separately in the same trial.