| Protection from sunburn with beta-Carotene--a meta-analysis ↗ | Skin redness after UV exposure | Participants in 7 small studies. The Stahl and Heinrich studies involved healthy, fair-skinned adults aged 20–57 and 22–55, respectively. | Beta-carotene and algae extracts containing beta-carotene and other carotenoids. The review table lists 15–180 mg/day, with some values referring to the whole blend. In Lee's study, participants took 30, 60, and 90 mg of the blend, equivalent to 29.4, 58.8, and 88.2 mg of beta-carotene, in successive 8-week periods. Duration: 3–24 weeks. Comparator: Studies used either placebo or the same participants' skin condition before supplementation as the comparator. | The review pooled results from 7 studies and found less redness, with a difference of 0.80 standard deviations (95% CI 0.20–1.40). This value is on a common statistical scale and cannot be read as a percentage of protection. The analysis included different blends and before-and-after comparisons, so it cannot give a precise estimate of the effect of pure beta-carotene. |
|---|
| Sunscreen and prevention of skin aging: a randomized trial ↗ | Skin aging on the back of the hand | 903 Australian residents younger than 55. Usable skin impressions were available for 886, and 604 had both measurements. | Beta-carotene tablets, 30 mg/day for 4.5 years. Comparator: Placebo tablets. Assignment to daily or usual sunscreen use was accounted for separately. | Beta-carotene did not slow skin aging on the back of the hand. The odds ratio for worsening of the skin rating was 0.95 (95% CI 0.74–1.22, p=0.69). Sunscreen was studied separately in the same trial. |
|---|
| A randomized trial of beta carotene supplementation and cognitive function in men: the Physicians' Health Study II ↗ | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation | Combined score across multiple tests in men after long-term supplementation | Memory for words and a story in men after long-term supplementation | Memory and thinking in men after short-term supplementation | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: 4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group
Combined score across multiple tests in men after long-term supplementation: 4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group
Memory for words and a story in men after long-term supplementation: 4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group
Memory and thinking in men after short-term supplementation: 1,904 male physicians older than 65, with 936 in the beta-carotene group and 968 in the placebo group | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: Lurotin beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day. Participants spent an average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program. Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.
Combined score across multiple tests in men after long-term supplementation: Lurotin beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day. Participants spent an average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program. Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.
Memory for words and a story in men after long-term supplementation: Lurotin beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day. Participants spent an average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program. Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.
Memory and thinking in men after short-term supplementation: Lurotin beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day for an average of 1 year. Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately. | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: The average score on the telephone-based TICS test was 34.41 with the supplement and 34.23 with placebo, a difference of +0.18 points out of 41 (95% CI 0.01–0.35). This was a small difference after many years of supplementation.
Combined score across multiple tests in men after long-term supplementation: The combined score across five tests was 0.047 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.00–0.09, p=0.03). This is a very small difference on the common test scale and cannot be interpreted as the proportion of memory regained.
Memory for words and a story in men after long-term supplementation: The overall verbal memory score was 0.063 standardized units higher with the supplement (95% CI 0.02–0.11, p=0.007). The score combined four tasks involving memorization and recall.
Memory and thinking in men after short-term supplementation: The supplement showed no advantage on the overall test score. The difference was −0.014 standardized units (95% CI −0.07 to 0.05, p=0.65). |
|---|
| Vitamin and mineral supplementation for maintaining cognitive function in cognitively healthy people in mid and late life ↗ | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation | Changes in memory and thinking in older women | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: 4,052 male physicians older than 65 at the time of memory testing, with 2,031 in the beta-carotene group and 2,021 in the placebo group
Changes in memory and thinking in older women: 2,824 female health professionals aged 65 or older with cardiovascular disease or at least three risk factors for it, with 1,406 in the supplement group and 1,418 in the placebo group | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: Lurotin beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day. Participants spent an average of 18 years in the long-term supplementation program. Comparator: Placebo. Other vitamins in the program were assigned separately.
Changes in memory and thinking in older women: Beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day for an average of 8.9 years. Four memory assessments over 5.4 years, with the first after 3.5 years of supplementation. Comparator: Placebo. Vitamin C and vitamin E were assigned separately. | Overall memory and thinking test in men after long-term supplementation: The average score on the telephone-based TICS test was 34.41 with the supplement and 34.23 with placebo, a difference of +0.18 points out of 41 (95% CI 0.01–0.35). This was a small difference after many years of supplementation.
Changes in memory and thinking in older women: The study did not detect a difference in the change in the overall test score. The estimate was +0.03 standardized units in favor of the supplement (95% CI −0.02 to 0.07, p=0.28). The estimate compares changes over the follow-up period rather than gains per year. |
|---|
| Vitamin E, vitamin C, beta carotene, and cognitive function among women with or at risk of cardiovascular disease: The Women's Antioxidant and Cardiovascular Study ↗ | Changes in memory and thinking in older women | 2,824 female health professionals aged 65 or older with cardiovascular disease or at least three risk factors for it, with 1,406 in the supplement group and 1,418 in the placebo group | Beta-carotene, taken orally at 50 mg every other day for an average of 8.9 years. Four memory assessments over 5.4 years, with the first after 3.5 years of supplementation. Comparator: Placebo. Vitamin C and vitamin E were assigned separately. | The study did not detect a difference in the change in the overall test score. The estimate was +0.03 standardized units in favor of the supplement (95% CI −0.02 to 0.07, p=0.28). The estimate compares changes over the follow-up period rather than gains per year. |
|---|